Wednesday, February 17, 2010

One State Four CMs

Political instability plagues many smaller states but none can match Meghalaya’s story. Ever since the state was formed in 1972, only two chief ministers, W A Sangma and S C Marak, have completed their full term in office. Think of any political jugglery to keep the government going and you would find it in Meghalaya--rotational chief ministers; independent legislator becoming the chief minister (F A Khonglam had done in 2001 what Madhu Koda did in 2006) and constitutionally unknown entities like deputy chief ministers.

Now comes the shocker. The state has four chief ministers. One constitutionally appointed by the governor and three others who have been given “rank and status of the chief minister”. They are: Donkupar Roy, state planning board chairman, J D Rymbai, chairman of Meghalaya economic development council and Friday Lyngdoh, Congress president and political advisor to the chief minister. The BJP rightly greeted the news of Lyndoh’s

Look at the current chief minister, D D Lapang’s career in the past decade-and-half. This is his fifth term as the chief minister, after he first occupied the high office in 1992. The term lasted barely a year. He again became chief minister in 2003 and remained in office till 2006 (his longest tenure so far). Then he occupied the high office thrice in the next three years, 2007, 2008 and 2009. The last time he was sworn in was on May 13, 2009.

Thursday, January 28, 2010

DK: Back of the Beyond













Tribal motif at a chowk in Jabalpur


Dandakaranya (or DK as bureaucrats and Maoists prefer to call it) lives up to the reputation it acquired in the days of the Ramayana—remote and forsaken. Then it was home to demons who spread terror all around, forcing the meditating rishis to seek Lord Rama’s help during his exile (which he did only to come to grief; demon king Ravana kidnapped his consort Sita). Now it is the Maoist heartland. If you are chasing the leftwing extremists, you end up in DK.

It is tough to go there. One major railways line passes through Raipur but the Bastar region (which forms the largest chunk of DK) is virtually untouched by the Railways. A minor line runs from Visakhapatnam to Bailadila mines in Dantewada. National highways have a better presence than the railways, but only just. The state has no transport service. So, the only way to reach Jagdalpur, divisional headquarters of Bastar, is to take a back-breaking journey of seven hours in a private bus. Even the 'luxury' buses don’t have push-back seats and ACs. The only consolation is that if one takes an overnight bus, there are sleepers, just like in the trains, above the rickety seats. Some have only sleepers and no chairs. Mosquitoes hum in your ears, as if singing lullabies to put you into sleep.

It is even tougher to move around in Bastar. The civilization exists only in dusty little district towns or faraway block and tehsil headquarters. Very few private buses connect them. There are private vehicles that can be hired but the choices are limited. You can move out of Jagdalpur in day time, but not far enough not to return before sundown. In Dantewada, two hours drive from Jagdalpur, it is worse. NH 16 that roughly bisects Bastar horizontally and connects Jagdalpur to Bijapur, is motorable for less than half-way through to Geedam in Dantewada. The Border Road Organisation is building the rest of the road for close to a decade but hasn’t progressed much because of constant attacks from the Maoists. Now under the CRPF presence the highway is dug up. Everyone advises you not to travel further.













A cop guarding the weekly haat in Kuakonda in Dantewada


Don’t ignore the advice. I did, travelling nearly 35 km of dug up road to reach Abujhmar-- Maoists’ main base in Bastar and spread over Narainpur and Bijapur districts -- only to abandon it because it became too painful for the back. A TI (SHOs are called Town Inspectors in this part of the country) warmed up to show the Salwa Judum camps that dot the road and road building work under security cover, only after surrounding himself with four commandos even in the broad daylight.

Venturing into the interior areas of Dantewada is equally daunting as one finds a few existing roads dug up at every few yards. Some of these have been levelled by the police but not tarred and are thus a virtual death trap as landmines can still be planted without anyone spotting them. There is no traffic, except for an occasional motorcycle rider or a few tribals walking to their destination, home or a weekly haat. There are hardly any villages in the sense you know it. A cluster of four or five huts, separated by miles of jungles, is all you get in the name of a village. (The area SP says it works to the advantage of Maoist militia who can easily melt into the forests and make it difficult for cops to keep a tab on their movement.)

The SP promises to provide a local guide to visit some of the bigger villages around which have pucca buildings (that house schools, hostels and aanganwadis), some of which have been destroyed by the ultras, both to prevent local youths studying beyond the primary level and security forces to set up camps. It turns out that the civilian is a commando carrying a revolver. The local TI says it is just to risky to travel unarmed into the interiors as it is swarmed with the Maoist sympathisers and the dalams.

It also turns out that the driver of the Bolero hired to move around was once a member of a dalam in Bijapur district. He narrates how once he attended a meeting addressed by Ganapathi, general secretary of CPI (Maoist), at the dead of night near his village a couple of years ago and insists that he speaks better English than I do. He also narrates how secret jungle meetings are a great party with dance performances and plenty of chicken and mutton curries.

It is too risky to travel with government officials, especially cops, in Bastar. Cops are risky in Malkangiri, the Orissa district that borders Dantewada and is part of DK, too but not the civil officials. In fact, one is safe with them as they have been co-existing peacefully with the Maoists for close to four decades. (District Collector Dr Nitin Jawale says Malkangiri has been the “resting place” of Maoists who moved around freely, even walking into police stations and sharing meals with the cops. It is only in the last decade that cases of looting armoury and violence were reported.)

No place is safe in Malkangiri, not even the district town. The Maoists had plastered notices threatening to blow up the biggest tribal fair of Orissa held here every year right at the fair ground little over a year ago. The fair ground is bang in the middle of the own and adjoins the Collectorate. The roads are fewer and worse than those in Bastar. The only partially motorable road into the interior areas leads to Chitrakonda (where 36 Greyhound commandos had been mowed down by the Maoists in mid-2008) on the Andhra border. Renting out a vehicle to go to Chitrakonda is a herculean task (no state transport here either). It takes nearly two hours to find one who agrees, but with the condition that we must return Malkangiri before sunset and that he be paid Rs. 1,000, though it is just 60 km away.

Bhubaneswar, the Orissa capital, is 650 km away. The nearest rail-head is a little over 100 km away at Jaypur in Koraput district (part of the starvation death land). It takes a three-hour taxi ride and 17-hour bus ride through the heart of Orissa to reach the capital city on roads that only those on the Moon can rival.

Wednesday, January 13, 2010

Playing hookey with hockey

Indian hockey is in a mess, once again. This time it is the Hockey India, an ad-hoc body set up in April 2008 to take the game out of a new low it had slumped into when India failed even to qualify for the Beijing Olympics, which is to be blamed. Less than two months to go for the hockey World Cup New Delhi is hosting, the players have gone on strike, refusing to participate in the training programme. They are protesting against non-payment of their salary and allowance ever since Hockey India replaced the disbanded Indian Hockey Federation nearly two years ago. The Hockey India management is, instead of resolving the issue immediately, accusing the players of giving precedence to money over their patriotic duty and pride in playing for the country. Here we must point out that unlike the cricketers, hockey players are a poorly paid lot with no star value or endorsement assignments. They get a paltry sum of Rs 25,000 per tournament (as against Rs 1.6 lakh a cricketer gets for playing a single ODI/T20 match and Rs 2.5 lakh for every Test!) and a small daily allowance. Their plight is understandable. What is not is Hockey India's attitude. It was mandated to bring transparency in the management of the game and democratise the IHF, which had become a personal fiefdom of KPS Gill, by holding elections by the end of 2008. It has failed in both (elections are now scheduled for February 7). Worse, instead of making the game more lucrative and paying salary on time, it is threatening to replace the striking national players with juniors for the World Cup! Where is your patriotic duty and pride in running the national game, Hockey India?

Tuesday, December 22, 2009

Wine is fine with our woman

March 5, 2009

Recently we witnessed the sad spectacle of a bunch of hoodlums belonging to a saffron brigade chasing and thrashing girls in a Mangalore pub in full media glare on the pretext that drinking by women was “not our culture’. There were plenty of protests and a public discourse followed (a woman minister now faces legal action for describing the assault as an attempt at “Talibanising” our society) but not a word was spoken against that not-our-culture assertion, which somehow left an impression that probably the hoodlums were right, howsoever silly may that seem in the land of Kamasutra, Tantra and Ganikas (remember Amrapali and Vasantasena?) Not to forget the dope-loving Lord Shiva, who all Hindu virgins are suppose to worship to be blessed with a good husband and the perpetually doped out Lord Indra, who presides over Heaven and should figure in the Guinness books for a record on chasing women!
With such a colourful and rich cultural heritage it would actually surprise if our past records didn’t show up women cheering up their evenings with an occasional drink or two or our menfolk so unimaginative or downright stupid as to deny themselves the pleasure of wine and women concoction. And guess what we found? There are plenty of delicious accounts!
Let us start with the profound and end up with the profane as the heady cocktail of wine and women takes its effect.

Sita and Draupadi
Our religious texts like Ramayana and Mahabharat are replete with references of royal ladies having gala evenings with generous use of wine. No less than Sita, the ideal wife and role model for all Hindu women, has been described sharing a drink with her Lord in the Ashok vatika after the demon king Ravana is killed! Yes, you read that right. She and her lord celebrated much as we would do in our age and time with, presumably, a cup of maireya, a ‘spiced liquor’, for that was her favourite drink.
(Ref: Economy and Food in Ancient India by Om Prakash; Wine in Ancient India by D.K. Bose and ‘Alcoholic fermentation and its products in ancient India’ by K.T.Achaya-who remains the first reference point for all food writers in India)

The books referred tells us further that maireya was a variety of Sura (Soma, that heavenly nectar that only the very privileged had access to and used in Vedic rituals, had presumably disappeared by then), a distilled liquor prepared from Guda (jaggery).

Sita even promises goddess Ganga, thousands jars of wine while accompanying her husband during his banishment thus: "Oh Goddess, be pleased, when we come back we shall propitiate you with thousands jars of wine."

We are told the women of monkey-king Sugriva were fond of wine. Queen Tara has been described in her intoxicated state with ‘uncertain gait and dancing eyes’. Yes, you would be right to check to closet of Ravana’s harem. There are passages that talk of the “charming women of demon king Ravana’s harem—sleeping beauties under the influence of liquor”.

Mahabharata has its own share. Here we quote: “Draupadi along with Subhadra, lovely sister of Krishna, went for a picnic on the bank of river Yamuna and enjoyed wine in the company of other women of the harem”. (M.L.Varadpande in “Women in Indian Sculpture”)
“Virtuous ladies like Sudesna (queen of King Virat with whom Draupadi stayed during her ‘agyantvas’) drank wine”. (Bose)

Soma and songs
Going further back in time, to the Vedic period and thereafter, when women had high status in society, when they studied and debated philosophy with men openly and participated equally in all important rituals, we find women had access and they enjoyed wine.

As far the heavenly nectar Soma—the very first wine known to India which had a prominent role in certain Vedic rituals apart from social use--is concerned no specific passage is found talking about women drooling to its effect (it was a very exclusive and expensive drink in any case and sourced from certain high mountains, the eponymous plant whose juice was extracted for preparing Soma, disappeared soon enough and heard no more) a Rig Vedic hymn lays bare the relation:
“Seven women stir thee with their fingers
blending their voices in a song to thee, you remind
the sacrificer of his duties at the sacrifice." (Bose)

As we travel through time (800 BC to 300 BC), we learn Sura (poor country cousin of Soma) had become a regular part of life, having found a place in several rituals. Om Prakash (referred earlier) writes that “it was served to women when a bride arrived at the bridegroom’s place” and that “women who performed a dance at the time of marriage were also served Sura”. It was also “served to the wives of forefathers in the Anavastakya rite”.
Elsewhere we find mention of a ritual in which young girls irrigating the Ashoka tree with ‘mouthfuls’ of wine (probably it had something to do with fertility rites).
What to make of another custom that talks of “drenching the limbs of young bride by sprinkling wine on her”! (Varadpande)

Wine and wonder
Coming down to the Christian era, we find wine turning even more irresistible part of life as a new discovery was made of its use. For, now we find wine being associated with beauty! Actually it was believed that wine imparted a ‘special charm’ to women and ‘heightened their beauty’ (how true!).
Om Prakash writes that during the Gupta period (300 AD to 750AD) “it was believed that intoxication gave a special charm to women; ladies of royal families, therefore, enjoyed drinking”.
He goes on to quote several instances:
“In the Malavikagnimitra, Iravati indulges in drinking. Indumati, the queen of Aja liked to receive wine from the mouth of her husband. The Mandasore inscription mentions a phrase, ‘like the cheeks of the intoxicated women’. The after effects of drinking on women are described in the Kumarasambhava. The Harshacharita also mentions beautiful ladies who had drunk wine. Kumarila mentions that in Ahicchatra (modern Ramnagar in Bareilly) and Mathura even Brahmin women indulged in drinking.”
“The Matsya Purana describes Krishna drinking with sixteen thousand ladies and doesn’t regard him as a sinner. Ajanta paintings also depict scenes of drinking such as wines being brought in large jars.”
“The Brahspati Smriti also lays down that drinking should be avoided by those women whose husbands are away.”
“The staple food grain of the people in north was wheat and women there drank liquors.”
“In Kumarila’s time Brahmin women in Ahicchatra (modern Ramnagar in Bareilly) and Mathura drank wine.”
“Even respectable women considered drinking wines a necessary embellishment.”

If these instances don’t make drinking of liquor by women a regular and essential part of our culture what would?

Nevertheless, we continue our journey to post Gupta Period (750 to 1200 AD). “Even some Brahmin youths wasted their time in company of dancing girls who were addicted to drinking. The sons of Harischandra by a Kshatriya wife are called madhupayina (addicted to drinking). Some women are described as intoxicated with drinking. Women liked the varuni variety of wine.”
“Medhatithi also says that while Brahmin women did not drink wine at festivals, Kshatriya and other women, to whom drinking was not forbidden, indulged in excessive drinking on festive occasions. Courtesans and Tantrikas were, no doubt, addicted to drinking.” (Bose)

‘Ornament of women’
Set aside those serious texts. Consider the literature, which has even more compelling descriptions indicating that not only was wine and women made an alluring concoction it was even glorified.
Kalidas too often spoke of ladies whose lips were scented with perfume of liquor! The Katha Sarit Sagara thus describes the drinking hall of King Naravahan Dutta. “It was full of goblets, made of various jewels, which looked like so many expanded lotuses and strewn with so many flowers, so that it resembled a lotus bed in a garden; and it was crowded with ladies with jugs full of intoxicating liquor, who made it flash like the nectar appearing in the arms of Garuda. There they drank wine- that snaps those fetters of shame that bind the ladies of the royal households, wine the essence of Love’s life, the ally of merriment!”
“In Mrichchkoti, we find that profligate youths came to the house of a woman, to drink iced wine. In Ratnabali we see at the ceremony in honour of the God of Love, citizens both male and female being drunk, reveling in song and dance.”
“We find wine is called ‘ornament of woman’. (Bose)


Women in Sene land
All the accounts given so far relates primarily to north India. What about southern part of India (part of the territory where Ram Sene, the hoodlums who said it was not-our-culture operate)? Well, going by the evidence, it is very clear that southern India (the Dravidian territory) was far more liberal and generous towards women even when it came to drinking. “Drinking wine after partaking of pepper and betal leaves was the general practice among the ladies of the south”. (Om Prakash)

Achaya agrees. The only passage in which he talks about drinking habits in south India, he wrote in his scholarly article in 1991 we have already referred to goes like this: “…..a favourite drink of women was munnir or triple-liquid, a mixture of tender coconut water, sugar-cane juice and palmyra juice, which may or may not have been fermented. Pre-Aryan society in the south showed no prejudice against (women) consuming liquor.”

Sculpture
Well, that is not all. Indian sculpture too provides its own share of evidence that well, you can’t really keep wine and women away from each other. We are told it was the Mathura school of sculpture that made drinking scenes popular in temple architecture. The National Museum has quite a few of sculptures that show woman with a wine cup.
At Sanchi (first century of Christian era), the earliest sculptures of Indian art, shows men and women drinking.
Yoginis and Ganikas were, of course, allowed their wine.

Wine and salvation
Ah, coming to the voluptuous Yoginis of our temples of love, lust and salvation. Whoever found that ‘magical route’ to salvation called Tantra must be laughing from the Heaven (surely he/she would have got salvation!). Tantra made women and wine essential parts of nirvana (Tantra didn’t spare even austere Buddhism or Jainism) and changed the face of our holy temples forever. India became the land of Kamasutra in sculpture too. Khajuraho is only one example. They are there in every nook and corner of the country.
One last quote to end. “Tantrikas gave religious sanctions to the use of wine and meat and the company of women, and associated pleasure with salvation in their teachings.” (Om Prakash)

Sculptures in national museum
1. woman serving liquor to pot-bellied man Kuber (kushan period)
2. young girl drinking from wine glass (kushan period)
3. drunk courtesan being helped

Monday, December 21, 2009

NaxalSpeak

Freedom movement
The Congress Party, and later the Gandhian leadership in the Congress, was brought forth by the British colonialists to divert and derail the growing anti-imperialist national liberation movement and to deprive the people of revolutionary leadership

Independence
The declaration of ‘Independence’ in 1947 was nothing but fake in essence. Actually the direct colonial and semi-feudal system of the British imperialists was replaced with semi-colonial and semi-feudal system under the neo-colonial form of indirect imperialist rule, exploitation and control.
Since India is semi-colonial and semi-feudal, neither there is real independence nor there is democracy. Therefore, this new democratic revolution will bring national independence uprooting the imperialist slavery, exploitation and control, and will establish the people’s democracy uprooting the feudal autocracy.

Green Revolution
After the transfer of power in 1947, the Indian ruling classes, in serving imperialism, resorted to several measures to promote alternative development models in place of radical land reforms based on "land to the tiller". Firstly, they brought forth community development programme, rural co-operatives and intensive agricultural development programmes (IADP) etc. with the aid of, and according to the needs and planning of, Ford and Rockefeller foundations, the World Bank and other imperialist agencies. Thereafter, in continuation of these steps they introduced the so-called Green Revolution in Punjab and some rural pockets of the country by the mid-1960s. This ‘Green Revolution’ was meant not only to provide captive market for the imperialist goods but also was an attempt to counter the emerging threat of the Red Revolution and to solve the chronic food crisis.

Parliament
In our country, parliamentary system was imposed by British imperialism from above. Moreover, bourgeois democratic revolution too has not been completed here. Hence no bourgeois democracy ever came into being here.
This state machinery is nothing but an instrument of suppression and repression, and represents the dictatorship of the comprador bourgeoisie and landlord classes subservient to imperialism. The repressive rule is sought to be covered up behind the façade of fraudulent parliamentary system. This state system represents the semi-colonial, semi-feudal system under neo-colonial form of indirect rule, exploitation and control.

Revolution
This new democratic state will be the people’s democratic dictatorship exercised by the united front comprising the proletariat, peasantry, petty-bourgeoisie and the national bourgeoisie class under the leadership of the proletariat based upon the worker-peasant alliance. The state will guarantee real democracy for the vast majority of the people while exercising dictatorship over the tiny minority of the exploiters. The minimum programme of our party is to establish socialism by accomplishing the new democratic revolution and the ultimate programme is to establish communism on a world scale.

Election boycott

In fact, the tactics of participation in the election in the name of using it is tantamount to abandoning the tasks of building and advancing the armed struggle. Reality is that without people’s political power everything is illusion. The people’s political power can be established and advanced only through the path of protracted people’s war. Parliamentary path and participation in the elections are completely incompatible with Protracted peoples war in the concrete conditions of India. Even the advancement of real people’s political consciousness is closely linked with it. More so, the accumulation of forces, including the development and Bolshevization of the party itself are inseparably linked with it. That is why the armed struggle is the ‘centre of gravity’ of the Party’s work as comrade Mao stated. In this overall context, the slogan of ‘Boycott Election’, though a question of tactics, acquires the significance of strategy in the concrete conditions of India. It is also correct to raise the slogan ‘Boycott Election is a Democratic Right’ on a mass scale.

Stand up to fight!

West Bengal Chief Minister Buddhadeb Bhattacharjee’s offer of talks with Maoists who abducted a policeman in West Midnapur district last Tuesday once again exposes our failure to deal with a hostage crisis. Just it had happened in the past, often with disastrous consequences, the first reaction of our governments both at the Centre and the state-level have been to bend backwards and get the hostages freed at any cost. There have been three major cases in the recent memory—Rubaiya Saeed’s abduction, hijack of IC-814 plane and abduction of three truckers in Iraq in 2004—and in all these cases the governments negotiated with the hostage takers. Ironically, every such capitulation followed by an uproar in the country after which the Centre solemnly declared its resolve to adopt a no-nonsense hostage policy the cornerstone of which would be ‘no negotiation’. But this has remained more as a statement of intent.
No lessons were learnt by the Rubaiya Saeed abduction case and some of the most dreaded international terrorists were released after the hijacking of IC-814 plane. The NDA regime seemed firm in putting in place the ‘no-negotiation’ policy but soon it was forgotten. When the UPA came to power in 2004, it did the same—first it went ahead and negotiated release of three truckers in Iraq and the then said India would henceforth follow US, China and Israel in adopting the policy of no-negotiations. The then National Security Advisor JN Dixit went to the extent of saying that it had the backing of Prime Minister Manmohan Singh. Dixit went on to say how Maulana Masood Azhar, who was released after the IC-814 hijack, was responsible for the death of 400 to 500 people thereafter!
Cut back to October 2009. Everything has been forgotten and the West Bengal government is now “waiting for a well-defined line of talks from the Maoist”. In turn, the Maoists have promptly sought release of detained ultras, declaring the abducted cop in their custody as a ‘prisoner of war’. Mind it, Maoist ultras have been declared terrorists and a massive operation is being launched against them by the Centre to reclaim the land from their clutches. If the West Bengal government is ready to buckle to free just one policeman, imagine what a big incentive it would be for the Maoists to attempt kidnapping a few more cops and if possible, some high-profile individuals. And what chance in the hell the state has in its battle against the Left-wing extremists! Your task, therefore, is cut out Mr Bhattacharjee: Don’t stoop to submit, rise to fight the menace!

Carry on Mr Thackeray!

Maharashtra Navnirman Sena chief Raj Thackeray’s declaration that he and his party would now take up the Marathi issue more stridently, which essentially means the hate campaign against the north Indians would continue unabated, should surprise none. After all, it paid rich dividend in the just concluded Assembly election in which his party won 13 seats! And he should be a worried man, readying for the big challenge confronting him: Migrants from UP and Bihar constitute half the population of Mumbai as per a recent BMC survey, as he pointed out. But that is not the only justification. As a politician he has every right to continue with his sectarian politics. Look at the main national opposition outfit, the BJP. It may moderate its Hindutva policies to please the allies at times but it essentially remains and espouses the cause of one particular religious community, the Hindus. Same is true of the Samajwadi Party, the Bahujan Samaj Party, the Rashtriya Janata Party, the DMK and many other political outfits which champion the cause of one or more caste groups. This parochial politics may have promoted divisive tendencies but the fact that it continues to pay good electoral returns clearly means that it is doing something good for the people. And that leads us to an issue of greater importance: our development plans are skewed. Why else would people from UP and Bihar crowd Mumbai in such large numbers? Why employment opportunities are not created uniformly across the country? Why some sections of the society continue to lag in terms of education and feel they are sons and daughters of lesser gods? In fact, Raj Thackeray’s policy of hate is symptom of the flaw in our policies and plans. And so long as we don’t take corrective measures, Thackerays would continue to flourish and practice politics of hate. To that extent, Raj Thackeray serves a great purpose by constantly reminding us of our shortcomings and the need for course correction.

Rebooting Economy 70: The Bombay Plan and the concept of AatmaNirbhar Bharat

  The Bombay Plan, authored by the doyens of industry in 1944 first envisioned state planning, state ownership and control of industries to ...